Russian Propaganda and the Baltic States: A Historical and Contemporary Overview

I asked ChatGPT to detail the history of Russian information operations targeting the Baltics in a series of seven prompts. My only edits were the removal of a handful of sentences to better improve the flow between sections.

Propaganda has long been used by governments and other institutions to influence public opinion and advance their own interests. The history of Russian propaganda directed at the Baltic states, which include Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, stretches back over a century and continues to the present day. From the time of the Russian Empire, through the Soviet era and into the post-Soviet period, Russia has employed a range of propaganda techniques to exert influence over the people of the Baltic states.

The earliest forms of Russian propaganda aimed at the Baltic states were in the form of printed material, including newspapers and pamphlets. During the First World War, Russian authorities sought to influence public opinion in the Baltic region by distributing propaganda leaflets in Estonian, Latvian, and Lithuanian. These leaflets were designed to create a sense of national solidarity among the various ethnic groups of the region and to promote loyalty to the Russian Empire.

During the Soviet era, propaganda was a central tool of state control. The Soviet government established a vast network of propaganda outlets in the Baltic states, including newspapers, radio and television stations, and cultural organizations. The content of this propaganda was designed to promote Soviet ideology and to portray the Soviet Union as a benevolent force in the region. In the early years of Soviet rule, this propaganda was successful in promoting loyalty to the Soviet state among many people in the Baltic states.

However, as the Soviet Union entered its decline in the 1980s, propaganda in the Baltic states became less effective. The rise of independent media and the spread of information from the West eroded the effectiveness of Soviet propaganda. In response, the Soviet government launched a new propaganda campaign designed to emphasize the threat of Western imperialism and to promote the idea that the Baltic states were an integral part of the Soviet Union.

With the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, Russian propaganda in the Baltic states underwent a significant shift. Rather than promoting Soviet ideology, Russian propaganda now focused on promoting a pro-Russian agenda. This agenda often included the portrayal of the Baltic states as backward and economically dependent on Russia, as well as the promotion of Russian cultural and linguistic influence in the region.

In recent years, Russian propaganda directed at the Baltic states has taken on a more aggressive tone. The Russian government has used social media and other online platforms to spread disinformation and propaganda designed to undermine the legitimacy of the Baltic states and to sow discord among the people of the region. This propaganda has included the promotion of conspiracy theories and the spread of false information about the Baltic states and their relationship with Russia. The current wave of Russian propaganda represents a significant challenge to the sovereignty and stability of the region.

Pre-Soviet Information Operations

Russian propaganda directed at the Baltic states has a long history that predates the Soviet era. The Russian Empire, which included the modern-day Baltic states of Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, sought to exert its influence over the region through a range of propaganda techniques.

In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the Russian Empire sought to promote its culture and language in the Baltic region. This propaganda campaign included the establishment of Russian-language schools and cultural institutions, as well as the publication of newspapers and other printed material in Russian.

At the same time, the Russian Empire sought to suppress the use of the Baltic languages, particularly in official settings. This policy of Russification was designed to promote loyalty to the Russian Empire and to undermine the development of national identities in the Baltic states.

In response to this policy, nationalist movements emerged in the Baltic states that sought to promote the use of their respective languages and to assert their cultural and political independence from Russia. These movements were often met with repression by the Russian authorities, who saw them as a threat to the stability of the empire.

Despite these efforts to suppress the development of national identities in the Baltic states, the nationalist movements continued to grow in strength. By the time of the Russian Revolution in 1917, the Baltic states had become a focal point of nationalist sentiment and resistance to Russian rule.

During the First World War, the Russian authorities sought to influence public opinion in the Baltic states by distributing propaganda leaflets in Estonian, Latvian, and Lithuanian. These leaflets were designed to create a sense of national solidarity among the various ethnic groups of the region and to promote loyalty to the Russian Empire.

However, these efforts were ultimately unsuccessful. The nationalist movements in the Baltic states continued to grow in strength, and with the collapse of the Russian Empire in 1917, the Baltic states declared their independence.

Soviet-Era Information Operations

Russian propaganda directed at the Baltic states during the Soviet era was a central tool of state control. The Soviet government established a vast network of propaganda outlets in the Baltic states, including newspapers, radio and television stations, and cultural organizations. The content of this propaganda was designed to promote Soviet ideology and to portray the Soviet Union as a benevolent force in the region.

Soviet propaganda in the Baltic states was aimed at promoting the idea of a socialist society and the benefits of membership in the Soviet Union. Soviet authorities used a range of techniques to promote this message, including the production of films, books, and other cultural materials that emphasized the achievements of the Soviet system.

The content of Soviet propaganda in the Baltic states was often tailored to local audiences. For example, in Estonia, Soviet propaganda emphasized the idea of a common history between Estonia and Russia, while in Latvia, Soviet propaganda emphasized the idea of a common Soviet identity shared by all ethnic groups in the region.

Despite these efforts, Soviet propaganda in the Baltic states faced significant challenges. The rise of independent media and the spread of information from the West eroded the effectiveness of Soviet propaganda. In the early 1980s, the Soviet government launched a new propaganda campaign designed to emphasize the threat of Western imperialism and to promote the idea that the Baltic states were an integral part of the Soviet Union.

This propaganda campaign was met with significant resistance from the people of the Baltic states, who continued to assert their national identities and demand greater political and cultural autonomy. In the late 1980s, this resistance culminated in the emergence of independence movements in the Baltic states that ultimately led to the collapse of the Soviet Union.

Post-Soviet Campaigns

After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991, Russian propaganda directed at the Baltic states underwent a significant shift. Rather than promoting Soviet ideology, Russian propaganda now focused on promoting a pro-Russian agenda. This agenda often included the portrayal of the Baltic states as backward and economically dependent on Russia, as well as the promotion of Russian cultural and linguistic influence in the region.

Russian propaganda in the post-Soviet era focused on the idea that the Baltic states were not truly independent, but rather were still under the influence of Western powers. Russian authorities often portrayed the Baltic states as vulnerable to external threats, and sought to present Russia as a protective force that could safeguard the security and well-being of the people of the region.

Russian propaganda in the post-Soviet era also promoted the idea of a common Russian identity shared by all ethnic Russians living in the Baltic states. This identity was often portrayed as being under threat from discrimination and repression by the Baltic governments, who were portrayed as hostile to ethnic Russians.

Russian propaganda in the post-Soviet era also focused on economic issues. Russian authorities often portrayed the Baltic states as being economically dependent on Russia, and suggested that the Baltic states could only achieve economic stability and prosperity by aligning themselves with Russia.

Despite these efforts, Russian propaganda in the post-Soviet era faced significant challenges. The people of the Baltic states, who had lived under Soviet rule for decades, were generally skeptical of Russian propaganda and remained committed to their independence and sovereignty. In addition, the spread of independent media and the rise of the internet provided people in the Baltic states with access to a range of alternative sources of information, which made it more difficult for Russian propaganda to exert influence.

In the early 2000s, Russian propaganda in the Baltic states became more aggressive. Russian authorities began using social media and other online platforms to spread disinformation and propaganda designed to undermine the legitimacy of the Baltic states and to sow discord among the people of the region. This propaganda often included the promotion of conspiracy theories and the spread of false information about the Baltic states and their relationship with Russia. Despite these efforts, the people of the Baltic states remained committed to their independence and sovereignty, and Russian propaganda faced significant challenges in the post-Soviet era.

Present Day Operations

Present day Russian propaganda campaigns directed at the Baltic states have taken on an increasingly aggressive tone. Russian authorities have used a range of tactics to spread disinformation and propaganda designed to undermine the legitimacy of the Baltic states and to sow discord among the people of the region.

One of the key themes of Russian propaganda in the present day is the idea that the Baltic states are not truly independent, but rather are under the control of Western powers. Russian authorities often portray the Baltic states as being at the forefront of NATO's expansion into Eastern Europe, and suggest that the presence of NATO forces in the region poses a threat to Russian security.

Russian propaganda in the present day also focuses on the idea of a common Russian identity shared by all ethnic Russians living in the Baltic states. Russian authorities often portray ethnic Russians as being under threat from discrimination and repression by the Baltic governments, and suggest that the Russian state has a responsibility to protect the rights of ethnic Russians in the region.

The conflict in Ukraine has played a significant role in Russian propaganda directed at the Baltic states. Russian authorities have used the conflict to promote the idea that Russia is surrounded by hostile forces that seek to undermine its security and well-being. They have also used the conflict to portray the Baltic states as being part of a larger Western conspiracy to encircle and contain Russia.

In addition to these propaganda campaigns, Russian authorities have also engaged in a range of other activities aimed at exerting influence in the Baltic states. These activities include the funding of pro-Russian political parties and media outlets, the use of cyberattacks to disrupt the functioning of Baltic governments and institutions, and the use of intelligence agencies to collect information on the political and economic activities of the Baltic states.

Despite these efforts, the people of the Baltic states remain committed to their independence and sovereignty. The spread of independent media and the rise of the internet have made it more difficult for Russian propaganda to exert influence, and the people of the Baltic states have become increasingly aware of the tactics used by Russian authorities to spread disinformation and propaganda.

Countering the Russian Threat

The Baltic states and NATO have a range of tools at their disposal to counter Russian propaganda directed at the Baltic states. These tools include both strategic communication efforts and efforts to promote media literacy and critical thinking among the people of the region.

One of the key strategies for countering Russian propaganda is to provide accurate and timely information to the people of the Baltic states. This can be achieved through a range of channels, including traditional media outlets, social media, and other online platforms. NATO's Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence, which is based in Riga, Latvia, has been instrumental in providing strategic communication support to the Baltic states and other NATO member countries.

In addition to these efforts, the Baltic states and NATO have also sought to promote media literacy and critical thinking among the people of the region. This includes efforts to educate people about the tactics used by Russian authorities to spread disinformation and propaganda, and to provide tools and resources that can help people identify and analyze these messages.

The Baltic states and NATO have also worked to engage with the people of the region in a more direct way. This includes efforts to increase participation in democratic processes, such as elections and other forms of civic engagement, and to promote cultural and educational exchanges that can help build understanding and cooperation among people from different backgrounds.

Another important strategy for countering Russian propaganda is to expose and counter false narratives and disinformation spread by Russian authorities. This can be achieved through fact-checking initiatives and other efforts to promote accurate information and to counter false or misleading claims.

Finally, the Baltic states and NATO can work to build resilience to Russian propaganda by strengthening their own institutions and societies. This includes efforts to promote transparency and accountability in government, to strengthen civil society and independent media, and to build strong and resilient economies that can withstand external pressures. By working together and adopting a multifaceted approach to countering Russian propaganda, the Baltic states and NATO can help build a more resilient and secure region.

Blogs of War generated this text in part with GPT-3, OpenAI’s large-scale language-generation model. Upon generating draft language, the author reviewed, edited, and revised the language to their own liking and takes ultimate responsibility for the content of this publication.